Thought I'd post this while the iron is hot, and Tina's been busy I see, as well as others....
A rough analysis of possible 2nd marriages for William James Taylor.
The sighting of him in Edge Lane makes me assume William J remarried 'close to home'. I have looked at all the Liverpool marriages from 1931 to 1940 and then found the brides' probable YoB to find their age at marriage. Might help to eliminate the improbable. For comparison I have inserted Val's WJT's estimated age after his name.
Because women usually married close to home, the brides' birth years are from birth searches in the Liverpool area, 1885 to 1920. Where an reasonable choice could not be made, such as too many as in the 1940 marriage to May Matthews, a ? has been used to indicate doubt. It was assumed that none of the brides were widows, with the possible exception of Rachel M McArdle.
Marriages Sep 1931: Taylor, William J [@46] & Ashton, Beatrice May - [bn 1901 = 30] - W.Derby - 8b - 849.
Marriages Mar 1932: Taylor, William J [@47] & Williams, Stella May - [bn 1890 = 42] - W.Derby - 8b - 573.
Marriages Sep 1933: Taylor, William J [@48] & Donaldson, Margaret A - [bn 1915 = 18] - W. Derby - 8b - 1286
Marriages Sep 1937: Taylor, William J [@52] & Bate, Ethel May - [bn 1904 = 33] - Liverpool N. - 8b - 1458.
Marriages Dec 1937: Taylor, William J [@52] & McArdle, Rachel M - [bn 1911? = 26?] - Liverpool S. - 8b - 341.
Marriages Jun 1940: Taylor, William J [@55] & Oulton, Nancy E - [bn 1915 = 25] - Liverpool S. - 8b - 99.
Marriages Dec 1940:
Taylor, William J [@55] & Matthews, May - [bn ?] - Liverpool S. - 8b - 571.
Taylor, William J [@55] & Knowles, Mary Irene - [bn 1908 = 32] - Liverpool N. - 8b - 1490.
On the basis of ages the most compatible appears to be the 1932 marriage to Stella May Williams, only a year after Robina died. The 1931 marriage is questionable. Would he have married within 3 months of Robina's death? And he would hardly have married an 18 year old in 1933, not in the 1930s anyway. Because his children shunned him after the 2nd marriage it must have been fairly soon after Robina's passing, say within a couple of years.
Open for debate...
DS